Mysteries of the Epicenter and Magnitude of China’s Mount Taishan Earthquake Solved

Volume 5, Issue 2, April 2021     |     PP. 17-41      |     PDF (2981 K)    |     Pub. Date: May 31, 2021
DOI: 10.54647/geosciences17111    94 Downloads     5912 Views  

Author(s)

TIAN Hongshui, School of Civil Engineering, Shandong Jianzhu University, Jinan, China
YANG Chuan-cheng, Earthquake Engineering Research Center of Shandong Province, Jinan, China
ZHANG Banghua, College of Surveying & Geo--informatics, Shandong Jianzhu University, Jinan, China
ZHANG Shenhe, School of Civil Engineering, Shandong Jianzhu University, Jinan, China

Abstract
The Mount Taishan earthquake, which named after Mount Taishan, occurred in 1831 BCE. It was the earliest historical earthquake recorded by historical writing-materials in China. However, seismic geologists have been unable to find any seismic-geological records or traces of the historical earthquake in the Taishan area and its surroundings. The epicenter and magnitude of this earthquake have remained unsolved mysteries. Through seismic and geological investigation and research, authors identified seismic records with soft-sediment deformation structures from the Holocene Heituhu Formation(Q4H) of the limnetic facies with soft soil layers in the Anqiu area (about 200 km from Mount Taishan) of the Yishu fault zone in the middle segment of the Tan-Lu fault zone, including seismic subsidence syncline, pinch-and-swell structure, as well as co-seismic micro-fault, and so on. Seismic subsidence synclines and pinch-and-swell structures were outcomes of the obvious thixotropic deformation of silting soft soils triggered by a strong earthquake. The micro-faults were co-seismic micro-fractures that occurred at the same time as the former. In the seismic subsidence synclines, there are two-fold layers: the older black-gray layer of silty soft soil (average thickness 0.65 m), and the newer yellow-gray sandy clay layer (average thickness 0.45 m) in the fold core. The 14C dating sample was taken from the top of the black-gray layer of silty soft soil, and the mean value of the 14 C dating results was converted into the year of AD, which got the result is that the time of the formation of the soft soil was about 1887 BCE. However, the 1887 BCE was not the time of the earthquake, which should earliest occur the formation time of yellowish-gray sandy clay layer in the syncline core. According to the deposition rate of faulted lakes, it is estimated that the duration of sediment formation of the sand-clay layer with a thickness of 0.45 m was about 60 years. Accordingly, the earthquake recorded by the seismically deformed soil-layers occurred in 1827 BCE, which coincides with the occurrence time (1831 BCE) of the Mount Taishan earthquake as per historical records. Therefore, the epicenter of the Mount Taishan earthquake should lie in the Anqiu area. Based on the IX-degree seismic intensity corresponding to the obvious thixotropy of the saturated cohesive soil from simulated seismic tests, the magnitude of this historical earthquake is calculated to be Ms 7.0. Based on the seismic intensity attenuation model, the seismic intensity near Mount Taishan induced by the earthquake is calculated as VI degrees.

Keywords
Mount Taishan earthquake, epicenter, Anqiu, magnitude, soft-sediment deformation structure, thixotropy, seismic subsidence

Cite this paper
TIAN Hongshui, YANG Chuan-cheng, ZHANG Banghua, ZHANG Shenhe, Mysteries of the Epicenter and Magnitude of China’s Mount Taishan Earthquake Solved , SCIREA Journal of Geosciences. Volume 5, Issue 2, April 2021 | PP. 17-41. 10.54647/geosciences17111

References

[ 1 ] Basilone L, 2017. Seismogenic rotational slumps and translational glides in pelagic deep-water carbonates. Upper Tithonian-Berriasian of Southern Tethyan margin (W Sicily, Italy).Sedimentary Geology 356, 1–14.
[ 2 ] Bowman D, Korjenkov A and Porat N, 2004. Late-Pleistocene seismites from Lake Issyk-Kull, the Tien Shan range, Kyrghyzstan. Sedimentary Geology, 163: 211–228.
[ 3 ] Cui Xin, Miao Qing-jie and Wang Jin-ping, 2010.Model of seismic intensity attenuation for North China. North China Earthquake Sciences, 28(2):18–22 (in Chinese with English abstract)..
[ 4 ] Chao H T, Li J L., Cui Z W, Man H M and Du X S, 1995. Active faults in Tanlu fault zone and hazards produced by the 1668 Tancheng earthquake (M=8.5). Marine Geology & Quaternary Geology, 15(3):69–79 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[ 5 ] Chao H T, Wang Z C, Li J L and Cui Z W, 1999. The latest activities of faults in the Taian region of Shandong Province and ‘Taishan Mountain earthquake’. Seismology and Geology, 21(2): 105–114(in Chinese with English abstract).
[ 6 ] Chen, X. Z., 2003. Soil Mechanics and Geotechnical Engineering. Tsinghua University Press (Beijing),1–536 (in Chinese).
[ 7 ] Diao Ting, 2010. Interpretation of the Mount Taishan earthquake in the 7th year of Emperor Fa’s reign during the Xia Dynasty. Recent Development in World Seismology , 376(4):36-44 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[ 8 ] Du Yuansheng, Xu Yajun and Yang Jianghai, 2008. Soft-sediment deformation structures related to earthquake from the Devonian of the eastern North Qilian Mts and its tectonic significance. Acta Geologica Sinica (English edition), 82(6): 1185–1193.
[ 9 ] Fu Xiaofang, Hou Liwei, Li Haibing, Wang Zongxiu and Zou Fuge, 2008. Coseismic deformation of the Ms 8.0 Wenchuan earthquake and its relationship with geological hazards. Acta Geologica Sinica, 82(2):1733–1746( in Chinese with English abstract).
[ 10 ] Goffredo M., Laura C, Marco B and Giacomo C，2002. Indicators of paleoseismicity in the lower to middle Miocene Guadagnolo Formation, central Apennines,Italy.Geological Society of America Special Paper,359: 87–98.
[ 11 ] He Bizhu, Qiao Xiufu, Tian, Hongshui, Chen Shuqing and Zhang Youxia, 2011. Paleo-seismic event and the giant dinosaur fossil burial of Later Cretaceous, Zhucheng, Shandong province, China. Journal of Palaeogeography 13(6):615–626 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[ 12 ] He Bizhu, Qiao Xiufu, Tian, Hongshui, and Zhang Youxia , 2012. Paleoseismic events of Early Cretaceous and dinosaur migration in Zhucheng of Shandong province, China. Acta Geologica Sinica, 86(6): 1320–1330 (in Chinese with English abstract ).
[ 13 ] He Bizhu, Qiao Xiufu, Zhang Y. L., Tian, H.S.,Cai Z.H., and Zhang Y.X., 2015, Soft-sediment deformation structures in the Cretaceous Zhucheng depression, Shandong Province, East China; their character,deformation timing and tectonic implications. Journal of Asian Earth Sciences 110:101–122.
[ 14 ] He B.Z. and Qiao X.F.,2015. Advances and overview of the study on paleoearthquake events: areview of seismites. Acta Geologica Sinica,(English Edition), 89(5): 1702–1746.
[ 15 ] Hou Wanguo, 1998. Application of Colloid Chemistry.Beijing:Science Press, 1-391 (in Chinese)..
[ 16 ] Knaust D. 2002. Pinch-and-swell structures at the Middle/Upper Muschelkalk boundary (Triassic): evidence of earthquake effects (seismites) in the Germanic Basin.International Journal of Earth Sciences, 90: 291-303.
[ 17 ] Li, D., Chen, P. X., Lü, X.F. and Chen X.L., 2011. Research progress summarization for the earthquake subsidence of soft soil. Earthquake Resistant Engineering and Retrofitting, 33(2):130-135 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[ 18 ] Li Hai-bing，Fu Xiaofang,VAN der Woerd J V, Si Jialiang,Wang Zongxiu，Hou Liwei，Qiu Zhuli，Li Ning, 2008.Co-seisimic surface rupture and dextral-slip oblique thrusting of the MS 8.0 Wenchuan Earthquake Acta Geologica Sinica, 82(2):1623–1643( in Chinese with English abstract)．
[ 19 ] Liang Lianji , Dai Fuchu , Jiang Hanchao and Zhong Ning, 2018. A preliminary study on the soft-sediment deformation structures in the late Quaternary lacustrine sediments at Tashkorgan, northeastern Pamir, China, Acta Geologica Sinica (English edition), 92(4): 1574–1591.
[ 20 ] Liu Baojun, 1980. Sedimentary petrology. Beijing: Geological Publishing House, 1–199 (in Chinese).
[ 21 ] Liu Huixian,1986.The Seismic Damages of the Great Tangshan Earthquake, Beijing:Seismological Press, 436－586(in Chinese).
[ 22 ] Lü Hongbo, Wang Jun and Zhang Haichun, 2011. Discovery of Late Mesozoic slump beds in Lingshan island, Shandong, and a pilot research on the regional tectonics. Acta Geologica Sinica 85(6): (in Chinese with English abstract).
[ 23 ] Martín-Chivelet, J., Palma,R. M., López-Gómez, J.and Kietzmann, D. A., 2011. Earthquake-induced soft-sediment deformation structures in Upper Jurassic open-marine microbialites (Neuquén Basin, Argentina). Sedimentary Geology 235: 210–221.
[ 24 ] Moretti, M, & Van Loon, A.J., 2014. Restrictions to the application of ‘diagnostic’ criteria for recognizing ancient seismites. Journal of Palaeogeography 3(1): 13–24.
[ 25 ] Montenat, C., Barrier, P., Ott d’Estevou, P. and Hibsch, C., 2007. Seismites: an attempt at critical analysis and classification. Sedimentary Geology, 196 :5–30.
[ 26 ] Qiao, X.F., Song, T.R., Gao, L.Z., Peng, Y., Li, H.B., Gao, M.i, Song, B.and Zhang, Q.D.,1994. Seismic sequence in carbonate rocks by vibrational liquefaction. Acta Geologica Sinica (English edition), 68(1):16–29.
[ 27 ] Qiao, X.F., Gao, L.Z., and Peng, Y., 2001. The Neoproterozoic in the paleo-Tancheng-Lujiang Fault Zone - catastrophe·sequences·biostratigraphy. Geological Publishing House (Beijing),1–122 (in Chinese).
[ 28 ] Qiao, X.F. and Li, H.B., 2009. Effect of earthquake and ancient earthquake on sediments. Journal of Palaeogeography ,11(6): 593–610 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[ 29 ] Qiao, X. F., Li, H.B. and Qiu, Z. L., 2013. Seismite: ancient earthquake records in sedimentary rocks.[In:] Feng, Z.Z.( eds.) Chinese sedimentary rock. Petroleum Industry Press (Beijing), 507–15 (in Chinese).
[ 30 ] Seilacher, A., 1969. Fault-graded beds interpreted as seismites. Sedimentology 13: 155–159.
[ 31 ] Shi, W., 2007. Engineering geology. Science Press (Beijing),1 –300 (in Chinese).
[ 32 ] Shi Zhen-liang and Li Yu-che, 2001. Seismic zonation in China. Engineering Science, 3(6):65-68(in Chinese with English abstract).
[ 33 ] Song, M.C. & Wang, P.C., 2003. Regional geology of Shandong Province , Jinan: Map Press of Shandong Province , 1–970 (in Chinese).
[ 34 ] Su Dechen and Qiao Xiufu, 2018.Thixotropic deformation features of cohesive sediments triggered by palaeo earthquakes. Journal of Palaeogeography, 20(4):609-622.
[ 35 ] Tian Hongshui, Wan Zhongjie and Wang Hualin, 2003. Discovery and preliminary study on seismites of the Cambrian Mantou Formation in the central Shandong area. Geological Rev., 49(2): 123–131 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[ 36 ] Tian Hongshui, Zhang Zengqi, Zhang Banghua, Zhu Jiewang, Sang Zhongxi and Li Hongkui, 2013. Tectonic taphrogenesis and paleoseismic records from the Yishu Fault Zone in the initial stage of the Caledonian movement. Acta Geologica Sinica (English edition), 87(4): 936–947
[ 37 ] Tian Hongshui, Zhang Banghua, Zhang, Shenhe and Lü, Mingying, 2014.Neogene seismites and seismic volcanic rocks in the Linqu area, Shandong Province, E China.Geologos 20(2), 125–137.
[ 38 ] Tian Hongshui, Van Loon, A. J., Zhang Zengqi, Zhang, Shenhe and Zhang Banghua, 2015a. Neogene Paleoseismic vents and the Shanwang Biota’s burial in the Linquarea, Shandong Province, China. Acta Geologica Sinica (English edition), 89(4): 1103–1119.
[ 39 ] Tian Hongshui, Zhang Aishe, Zhang Shenhe, Zhang Banghua, Zhu Jiewang, Lü Mingying . 2015b. Simulation earthquake tests and liquefied deformations of the saturated lime-mud. Beijing: Seismological Press, 1-78 (in Chinese).
[ 40 ] Tian Hongshui, Van Loon, A. J., Wang Hualin, Zhang Shenhe and Zhu Jiewang, 2016a. Seismites in the Dasheng Group: new evidence of strong tectonic and earthquake activities of the Tanlu Fault Zone. Science China Earth Sciences, 59 (3): 601–618.
[ 41 ] Tian Hongshui, Zhang Shenheand Zhang Aishe, 2016b. Test investigation on liquefied deformation structure in saturated lime-mud composites triggered by strong earthquakes. Acta Geologica Sinica (English edition), 90(6): 2008-2021.
[ 42 ] Tian Hongshui, Zhu Jiewang, Wang Hualin, 2017.Spatio-temporal distribution and significance of seismic event horizons in the Yishu Fault Zone and its adjacent area. Journal of Palaeogeography, 19(3): 393–417( in Chinese with English abstract)．
[ 43 ] Tian Hongshui, Wang Hualin, Zhu Jiewang and Zhang Shenhe, 2018. Earthquake-caused seismic volcanic rocks and thixotropic deformations of soft muddy sediments in Early- Cretaceous Shijiatunduan Member, Jiaozhou City. Seismology and Geology, 40(2):361–375.
[ 44 ] Van Loon, A.J., 2009. Soft-sediment deformation structures in siliciclastic sediments: an overview. Geologos 15, 3–55.
[ 45 ] Van Loon, A.J. and Su Dechen, 2013. Deformed stromatolites in marbles of the Mesoproterozoic Wumishan Formation as evidence for synsedimentary seismic activity. Journal of Palaeogeography 2, 390–401.
[ 46 ] Wei Guangxing and Sun Zhaomin, 2000. History of Natural Disasters in Shandong Province. Seismological Press (Beijing), 1– 256 (in Chinese).
[ 47 ] Wu Wujun, Zeng Zuoxun and Zhu Wenge, 2005. Research on rheology gauge of fish-head boudin. Advances in Earthscience 20, 925-932 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[ 48 ] Wheeler R.L., 2002. Distinguishing seismic from nonseismic soft-sediment structures: criteria from seismic-hazard analysis [In:] Ettensohn, F.R., Rast, N. & Brett, C.E. (Eds): Ancient seismites. Geological Society of America Special Paper 359: 1-11.
[ 49 ] Yang Jianping, Wang Yali, Zha Ming and Mu Xuemei, 2006. Discovery of the seismite surge wave deposits records of Paleogene in Huimin Depression, Shandong Province. Acta Geologica Sinica, 80(11): 1715–1720 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[ 50 ] Yin Xiulan. and Yang Tiannan, 2005. Seismites in the Laiyang Group in the Jiaozhou-Laiyang Basin, Shandong Province, and their tectonic implications. Geological Reviews 51, 502-507 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[ 51 ] Yuan Jing, 2004. The property and geological significance of seismites of Paleogene in Huimin sag, Shandong province. Acta Sedimentologica Sinica 22, 41-46 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[ 52 ] Yu Shousong and Shi Zhaoji, 1989. Experimental investigation of soil settlement due to earthquake. Chinese Journal of Geotechnical Engineering, 11, 35-46 (in Chinese with English abstract).
[ 53 ] Zhang Mingli, Jin Zhijun, Lű Pengju and Liu Guoli, 2000. Formation of Mount Taishan and Cenozoic tectonicism. Journal of Geomechanics, 6(2):23-29(in Chinese with English abstract).
[ 54 ] Zhang Huchen, 1989. Study on the earthquake thixotropy of mucky soil foundation.Chinese Journal of Geotechnical Engineering, 11, 78-85 (in Chinese with English abstract ).
[ 55 ] Zhang Jiuqi,Sun Rui,Yuan Xiaoming and Hou Longqing, 2017.The simplified formula for calculating the permanent strain potential of soft soil and parameter analysis.Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Dynamics, 37(5):103-108(in Chinese with English abstract ).